• Poor 1Q results within expectations. Bursa’s 1QFY08 net profit declined by a hefty 40% yoy and 14.9% qoq to RM42.1m, dragged by subdued trading activities in the equity market. Although 1Q net profit only accounted for 20.6% of our fullyear forecast and 17.7% of consensus, we regard the results as within expectations as we envisage stronger earnings in the 2H, banking on the potential recovery in the equity market. As expected, no dividend was declared in the 1Q.
• Dismal equity performance. 1Q revenue plunged by 26.6% yoy to RM93.8m, affected by poor performance of the equity market. The market velocity dropped to 46%, from a high of 68% in the 1QFY07, leading to a decline in daily trading value from RM2.8bn to RM2bn. Meanwhile, the group’s effective clearing fee rate also dropped to 2.3% from 2.7%, due to the negative impact from the new fee structure and lower retail participation in the market.
• Lower derivative income. The daily average contracts for the derivative market rose by 16.2% to 30,283. However, derivative revenue was down by 5.4% yoy to RM12.2m, due to the revised derivative fee structure.
• Retain earnings forecasts. Despite the poor 1Q, we are keeping our earnings forecasts unchanged as we anticipate stronger earnings for Bursa in the 2H,banking on potential recovery in the equity market. In fact, we had slashed our earnings forecasts by 30-32% in the previous report dated 18 Mar 08 to reflect the likely weaker market sentiment in the coming months.
• Maintaining target price. We are keeping our target price of RM8.35, still pegged to FY09 P/E of 20x, which is above the 15x average for the major bourses globally. The premium is premised on potential recovery in the 2H and M&A newsflow as NYSE Euronext and Chicago Mercantile Exchange are reported to be eyeing a stake in Bursa.
• Reiterate TRADING SELL. We maintain our TRADING SELL recommendation on the stock predicated on the de-rating catalysts of (1) weak market sentiment leading to dimmed earnings prospects in the next 1-2 quarters, and (2) continued negative impact from the new fee structure.
Custom Search
Showing posts with label Bursa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bursa. Show all posts
Saturday, 3 May 2008
Tuesday, 15 April 2008
KENANGA : Bursa - BUY - 15 Apr 2008
Bursa Malaysia – Challenging year ahead (Company Update)
Price: RM8.45
Target Price: RM9.70
Recommendation: BUY
· Lethargic trading momentum. Initially affected by global market uncertainties, pressure on trading activities is compounded further by political uncertainties following the recent 12th general election. Consequently, previous anchor themes such as fiscal stimulus, the 9th Malaysian Plan and robust M&A activities have been played down, causing investors’ appetite and sentiment to the market to wane off.
· Daily trading volume and daily trading value remain undoubtedly thin. The daily average trading volume and value in 1Q08 declined by a significant 55.5% and 26.7% YoY to 925.8m shares and RM2.0b, respectively.
· Earnings downgrade. We are lowering our FY08 and FY09 net profit estimates by 16-19% on the back of revised daily average trading value to RM2.1b and RM2.2b from RM2.6b and RM2.8b for FY08 and FY09, respectively.
· We also believe the new clearing fee structure (from 4bps of contract value to 3bps while cap was doubled to RM1,000 effective from 1 Jan, 2008) to depress Bursa’s effective clearing fee by approx. 8% which will drag down its potential revenue.
· Collaboration with Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME). Management expects to conclude talks with CME, the world’s largest derivative market, by end of the year which will assist the Group to further re-engineer its business. A successful potential collaboration will act as a re-rating catalyst for Bursa, in our view.
· Dividend payout of at least 90% is likely to be maintained. Despite reducing our gross DPS estimates for FY08 and FY09 from 85sen to 60sen and 65sen, respectively, following the earnings revision, Bursa’s gross dividend yield of 7.1% is still appearing more attractive vis-à-vis its peers.
· Cautious against market uncertainties but downside risks appear limited due to its: (1) decent dividend yield and (2) recent sharp share price correction of 49% from RM16.60 high. Upgrade to BUY, Target Price of RM9.70 based on PER of 20x to estimated FY08 EPS of 40.7sen and RM1.60/share of cash at hand value at book.
KENANGA INVESTMENT BANK BERHAD (15678-H)
Price: RM8.45
Target Price: RM9.70
Recommendation: BUY
· Lethargic trading momentum. Initially affected by global market uncertainties, pressure on trading activities is compounded further by political uncertainties following the recent 12th general election. Consequently, previous anchor themes such as fiscal stimulus, the 9th Malaysian Plan and robust M&A activities have been played down, causing investors’ appetite and sentiment to the market to wane off.
· Daily trading volume and daily trading value remain undoubtedly thin. The daily average trading volume and value in 1Q08 declined by a significant 55.5% and 26.7% YoY to 925.8m shares and RM2.0b, respectively.
· Earnings downgrade. We are lowering our FY08 and FY09 net profit estimates by 16-19% on the back of revised daily average trading value to RM2.1b and RM2.2b from RM2.6b and RM2.8b for FY08 and FY09, respectively.
· We also believe the new clearing fee structure (from 4bps of contract value to 3bps while cap was doubled to RM1,000 effective from 1 Jan, 2008) to depress Bursa’s effective clearing fee by approx. 8% which will drag down its potential revenue.
· Collaboration with Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME). Management expects to conclude talks with CME, the world’s largest derivative market, by end of the year which will assist the Group to further re-engineer its business. A successful potential collaboration will act as a re-rating catalyst for Bursa, in our view.
· Dividend payout of at least 90% is likely to be maintained. Despite reducing our gross DPS estimates for FY08 and FY09 from 85sen to 60sen and 65sen, respectively, following the earnings revision, Bursa’s gross dividend yield of 7.1% is still appearing more attractive vis-à-vis its peers.
· Cautious against market uncertainties but downside risks appear limited due to its: (1) decent dividend yield and (2) recent sharp share price correction of 49% from RM16.60 high. Upgrade to BUY, Target Price of RM9.70 based on PER of 20x to estimated FY08 EPS of 40.7sen and RM1.60/share of cash at hand value at book.
KENANGA INVESTMENT BANK BERHAD (15678-H)
Tuesday, 1 April 2008
Merrill Lynch - Bursa; target now 5 !!
More downside from fee cuts and reduced trading velocity
Multiple challenges ahead; maintain Sell We see three key challenges for Bursa Malaysia in 2008: (1) falling trading velocity on the Malaysian stock market, (2) introduction of a new clearing fee structure that we expect to be revenue-negative, and (3) potential P/E multiple compression as growth expectations get ratcheted down. M&A is a wild card for any exchange, but we do not think it is worth paying for. Merrill Lynch’s fair value for Bursa is RM5/share, translating to 13x FY08E P/E.
Trading velocity has slowed by 30% since early 2007 Equity trading activity peaked at an average RM2.8bn per day in 1Q07, but has slowed steadily since then. It currently averages just RM2.0bn per day. The increased political uncertainty in Malaysia following the general elections on 8 March could further depress market sentiment and stock-market turnover.
New clearing fees likely to be revenue-negative
We remain surprised by the analyst community’s lack of attention to the impact from cuts to regulated stock-market clearing fees that took effect 1 January 2008. The changes were announced in Malaysia’s Budget late last year. We believe that the net impact from the change in clearing fees will be revenue-negative. ML’s profit estimates 17%/18% below consensus in 08/09 We have lowered our average daily equity trading assumptions to RM2.0bn (from RM2.4bn) in FY08 and RM2.2bn (from RM2.7bn) in FY09 to reflect a much more subdued outlook for market turnover. This leaves our profit
estimates for Bursa at 17%/18% below consensus in FY08/09.
Multiple challenges ahead; maintain Sell We see three key challenges for Bursa Malaysia in 2008: (1) falling trading velocity on the Malaysian stock market, (2) introduction of a new clearing fee structure that we expect to be revenue-negative, and (3) potential P/E multiple compression as growth expectations get ratcheted down. M&A is a wild card for any exchange, but we do not think it is worth paying for. Merrill Lynch’s fair value for Bursa is RM5/share, translating to 13x FY08E P/E.
Trading velocity has slowed by 30% since early 2007 Equity trading activity peaked at an average RM2.8bn per day in 1Q07, but has slowed steadily since then. It currently averages just RM2.0bn per day. The increased political uncertainty in Malaysia following the general elections on 8 March could further depress market sentiment and stock-market turnover.
New clearing fees likely to be revenue-negative
We remain surprised by the analyst community’s lack of attention to the impact from cuts to regulated stock-market clearing fees that took effect 1 January 2008. The changes were announced in Malaysia’s Budget late last year. We believe that the net impact from the change in clearing fees will be revenue-negative. ML’s profit estimates 17%/18% below consensus in 08/09 We have lowered our average daily equity trading assumptions to RM2.0bn (from RM2.4bn) in FY08 and RM2.2bn (from RM2.7bn) in FY09 to reflect a much more subdued outlook for market turnover. This leaves our profit
estimates for Bursa at 17%/18% below consensus in FY08/09.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)